The Christmas season is filled with joy, love, and the remembrance of Jesus’ birth. But while we know that Christ’s arrival is the true origin of Christmas, there are some important questions some might have about the real history of Christmas.
It’s not uncommon to hear questions such as: “Is Christmas a pagan holiday?” and “Why is Christmas on December 25?” among other curiosities. That’s why we’re setting out to help explain the real history of Christmas and to help clear up any misconceptions about this important and transformational holiday.
The Real History of Christmas
What is the origin of Christmas, you ask? Well, from a Christian perspective it all goes back to the Bible. The birth of Jesus, as told in the gospels — and as foretold in the Old Testament — is the real origin of Christmas.
The history of Christmas surrounds Mary, Joseph and the birth of the promised king. Luke 2 is one of the most important chapters in the Bible where this story is discussed. The real history of Christmas can be found, in part, in Luke 2:4-7 (NIV):
“So Joseph also went up from the town of Nazareth in Galilee to Judea, to Bethlehem the town of David, because he belonged to the house and line of David. He went there to register with Mary, who was pledged to be married to him and was expecting a child. While they were there, the time came for the baby to be born, and she gave birth to her firstborn, a son. She wrapped him in cloths and placed him in a manger, because there was no guest room available for them.”
In the U.S., Christians (and Americans more generally) have celebrated Christmas as a federal holiday since 1870. That said, Christmas has been celebrated across the globe since around the fourth century, History reported.
As we explore the history of Christmas, it seems Christians didn’t initially celebrate Jesus’ birth for the first few hundred years of the church’s existence, focusing instead on his death and resurrection.
Why Is Christmas on December 25th?
One of the big questions that emerges when we explore the history of Christmas is why Christians chose December 25 as the date to celebrate Christ’s birth. It’s a legitimate question about the history of Christmas, considering that the Bible doesn’t mention a date for Jesus’ birth.
So, why is Christmas on December 25? As it turns out, this part of the origin of Christmas story gets a little confusing and muddled, but there are actually a number of theories surrounding the reason for the date choice.
According to The Washington Post, in the year 200 A.D., early Christians believed Jan. 6 was the date of Jesus’ birth. While the reason for this selection isn’t known, by the year 400, that date reportedly moved to Dec. 25. The history surrounding that date is also a bit muddled.
This is where the real history of Christmas becomes difficult to discern. Some claim there is a pagan origin of Christmas, though others dispute this fact. In the Post’s own analysis of the Dec. 25 date, reporter Valerie Strauss concluded: “Bottom line: Nobody knows for sure why Dec. 25 is celebrated as Christmas.”
Strauss also dove deep on claims surrounding the pagan origins of Christmas, presenting both the theory that Christians chose Dec. 25 in an effort to essentially co-opt pagan celebrations happening at the same time as well as the idea that the date might have had little to do with the quest to phase out these celebrations in favor of a Jesus-centric holiday.
Some historians like Candida Moss have also noted that there’s at least one clue in the gospels that could point to a different time of year when Jesus was born. Speaking of the Gospel of Luke, she noted that the shepherds were looking over their flocks.
This is important, as she said, “shepherds would have been watching their flocks only during the lambing season in the spring.”
Saturnalia: Pagan Origin of Christmas?
Any deep-dive exploration of the history of Christmas and, more specifically, the question, “Is Christmas a pagan holiday?” will yield information on Saturnalia. First, let’s explore the meaning of Saturnalia and its practices and then we can move forward from there.
Saturnalia, a holiday honoring the Roman god Saturn, was the most widely-celebrated Roman festival. The festival was originally celebrated on December 17, but eventually was extended to seven days, with businesses closing, slaves gaining temporary freedom and other restrictions briefly taken off the books, Britannica noted.
The origin of Christmas is unique to Jesus, but the Dec. 25 date — as noted above — continues to be debated, particularly when it comes to claims of pagan celebrations. History noted that “it is commonly believed that the church chose this date in an effort to adopt and absorb the traditions of the pagan Saturnalia festival.”
It’s important to note that some sources also frame the celebrations as being filled with chaos and debauchery. It’s clear that the popularity of Christmas superseded that of Saturnalia and, over time, became an internationally dominant holiday.
“The early motive for celebrating Jesus’ birth on December 25 may have been akin to that which inspires modern churches to hold ‘fall festivals’ or ‘Bible costume parties’ on October 31. That is, Christians desire to provide a spiritually positive alternative to what they perceive as a pagan celebration. Over time, as the Roman Empire was Christianized, customs associated with Saturnalia were ‘cleaned up’ and absorbed into the celebration of Christmas.”
This is a powerful thought to take into account when exploring the origin of Christmas and responding to claims surrounding the real history of Christmas.
Without a doubt, the choosing of the date to help strategically phase out Saturnalia would have been a smart move on Christians’ part, pending these historical assumptions mesh with reality. Others, though, take a different approach to the available information on the subject.
Moss wrote that there was a disconnect in timing, explaining that the date for Christmas was set by Pope Julius I in the 4th century, but it wasn’t until the 7th century that “Pope Gregory the Great instructed bishops to celebrate saints’ feast days on the days of pagan festivals.”
The historian posited that Dec. 25 was chosen due to the fact that it was exactly nine months from March 25, a date traditionally believed to be Jesus’ crucifixion. Why, you ask?
One element of understanding this theory on the origin of Christmas is realizing that some Christians came to believe that Jesus was conceived and crucified on the same day, which would explain these dates.
So, that’s a fair bit of information surrounding the history of Christmas. When you go deep into these details, it’s clear the answer is “no” when someone asks, “Is Christmas a pagan holiday?” or makes claims that Christmas was manufactured and stolen from pagans.
That said, understanding the real history of Christmas is incredibly helpful and offers us insight into how one of the most important days in human history came to be celebrated across the globe.
Want more Christmas? Head on over to check out our guide of some of the best Christmas movies streaming right now on PureFlix.com. You can stream movies and shows like “The Nativity” and “The First Christmas Town” right now on PureFlix.com.